"Why do Jews always answer a question with a question?"
- curious reader
"How should they answer?"
- Dear Abby
"No, really, why do Jews always answer a question with a question?"
- same curious reader
"Well, how else are we supposed to learn?"
- Morah Jen (taking over for Dear Abby)
"But there's got to be a reason, right? Like a real reason?"
- increasingly frustrated reader
"Sure. What do you think the reason is?"
- Morah Jen
"Ok, I'm sensing your frustration.
Jews answers questions with questions because for us it's not about the answers. We're not really looking for the answer. How can we ever know the answer is the right answer? Or the only answer? So it's not about the answer.
It's about the questions. It's about the journey. It's our struggle with the questions that connects us to our history, our ancestors, and to God. We find holiness in asking questions and debating what the answer is.
Also, it's just good pedagogy. Read this article to learn more."